陳 少琪的部落格

What is Trump, Elon Reeve Musk Doctrine: An Engineer's Perspective

The global landscape of trade and manufacturing is facing a period of considerable upheaval, largely influenced by policy shifts in major economies. For smaller nations that have built their economies on manufacturing and export, particularly those in Asia, the anti-globalization strategies adopted by the Trump administration have created a complex web of challenges. These nations now grapple with the instability of rapidly changing tariffs and the unpredictable fluctuations of exchange rates. Understanding the roots of these policies, often referred to as "Trumpism," is crucial to navigating this uncertain environment. Furthermore, the evolving discourse around Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles, marked by skepticism from established voices like The Economist and outright opposition from figures like Elon Musk, adds another layer of complexity. This is particularly intriguing given the success of companies like Tesla, whose very existence is predicated on the shift towards a greener economy, a shift often championed by the same neoliberal policies that promote ESG. Drawing upon years of experience as an electrical engineer witnessing these economic shifts firsthand, this report aims to dissect these intertwined issues in a clear and accessible manner.

The Shifting Sands of Global Trade: How Anti-Globalization Impacts Smaller Manufacturing Hubs

The anti-globalization strategy spearheaded by the Trump administration, encapsulated by the "America First" slogan 1, has fundamentally reshaped international trade. This approach has manifested most prominently in protectionist trade policies, with a particular focus on China.2 This has ushered in an era of tariff instability, where smaller economies heavily reliant on manufacturing are constantly facing uncertainty regarding the cost of exporting their goods to significant markets like the United States.

The imposition of tariffs, often enacted unilaterally and at substantial rates – reaching as high as 50% in some instances 3 – immediately translates to increased costs for businesses located in countries such as Vietnam, Thailand, and Malaysia, all of which are significant exporters to the US.4 Vietnam, for example, has emerged as a critical manufacturing hub for a wide array of goods, including electronics, textiles, and footwear. This nation faced the prospect of a sweeping 46% tariff on all its exports destined for the US.6 Such a drastic increase could trigger a broad economic downturn across multiple sectors within Vietnam, leading to reduced GDP growth and a significant outflow of capital.6 Similarly, Thailand's economy, which is deeply intertwined with global exports, was projected to experience a contraction in its GDP for two consecutive quarters as a direct consequence of US tariffs.7 Economic experts forecasted a decline in both Thai exports and overall manufacturing capacity, which in turn would negatively impact household income levels and consumer spending.7 Malaysia, with the United States serving as its second-largest export market 9, was confronted with a 24% blanket tariff on its goods entering the US.9 This measure posed a substantial threat to Malaysia's robust manufacturing sector, potentially leading to a decrease in demand for its products and a squeeze on the profit margins of local businesses.9

The sudden and substantial nature of these tariff hikes introduced an unprecedented level of uncertainty into established global supply chains. Businesses that had meticulously optimized their operations for maximum global efficiency now had to confront the reality of drastically altered cost structures. This forced many to consider absorbing significant losses, passing on the increased costs to consumers through higher prices 12, or even undertaking the complex and expensive process of relocating their production facilities.4 This environment of instability inevitably deters long-term investment and makes strategic planning exceedingly difficult for these smaller economies. The primary aim of the Trump administration's policies was to incentivize the return of manufacturing to the United States. While tariffs do make imported goods more expensive, theoretically making domestic production more attractive, the immediate consequence for countries heavily reliant on exporting to the US is a direct economic penalty, potentially leading to downturns and widespread business disruptions. This creates a highly volatile situation where businesses cannot reliably predict their operational costs or their access to crucial international markets.

Furthermore, the "reciprocal" nature of these tariffs 15 was predicated on the argument that other nations imposed unfairly high tariffs on goods originating from the United States. However, countries like Malaysia contested this premise, pointing out that their average applied tariff rates were considerably lower than what the US administration claimed.9 This discrepancy highlights a potential fundamental flaw in the justification used for imposing these tariffs and could be interpreted as a punitive measure rather than a corrective one aimed at achieving fair trade. Such misrepresentations could easily escalate trade tensions unnecessarily.

Decoding "Trumpism": Understanding the Core Principles

"Trumpism," also frequently referred to as the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement, represents a distinct political movement within the United States, closely associated with Donald Trump and his significant political base.18 At its core, Trumpism incorporates ideologies such as right-wing populism, a strong sense of American nationalism, nativism, and a stance of right-wing antiglobalism.18

A central tenet of Trumpism is the principle of "America First" 1, which prioritizes the interests of the United States above all international commitments.19 This philosophy translates into a strong emphasis on economic protectionism, with the stated goals of bringing manufacturing jobs back to American soil and significantly reducing the nation's trade deficits.1 Trumpism also frequently expresses a deep-seated skepticism and hostility towards the established political order and intellectual elites. It resonates with a feeling of being overlooked and harmed by the government among working-class Americans.1 The movement champions the idea of "industrial might" and places a high value on tangible outcomes, such as the creation of domestic manufacturing jobs, often dismissing traditional ideological objections to government intervention in the economy.19

Trumpism is more than just a collection of specific policy proposals; it represents a political ideology deeply rooted in a particular interpretation of American national identity and a profound rejection of the prevailing political and economic status quo. The strong emphasis on both nationalism and populism serves as the driving force behind the protectionist trade policies that have had such a direct and significant impact on global supply chains. This ideology taps into a powerful sentiment of national pride and a widespread feeling that the interests of the "common person" have been ignored or actively undermined by a detached and self-serving elite. This translates into policy decisions that prioritize the growth and well-being of domestic industries and American jobs, often at the expense of established international trade agreements and broader global cooperation.

Furthermore, the Trumpism movement has also been observed to exhibit illiberal and, at times, authoritarian tendencies. This includes the propagation of a belief that the President of the United States is above the rule of law.18 This particular aspect of Trumpism can further destabilize international relations, as other nations may perceive the US as an unpredictable and unreliable partner, potentially willing to disregard established global norms and agreements in pursuit of its own narrowly defined national interests. This unpredictability can make it exceedingly difficult for other countries to engage in stable and long-term economic partnerships with the United States.

The ESG Debate: A Clash of Ideologies and Economic Realities

The principles of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) have become increasingly prominent in investment and corporate strategy. However, these principles have also faced growing scrutiny and skepticism from various quarters.

The Economist, a highly respected global publication, has voiced concerns regarding ESG investing, questioning the reliability of its metrics, the consistency of its application, and its overall effectiveness in achieving meaningful real-world impact.26 A key concern revolves around the lack of standardized metrics for ESG ratings, which leads to significant inconsistencies in how different rating agencies evaluate companies.28 This lack of uniformity makes it challenging for investors to make accurate comparisons of companies' ESG performance and creates opportunities for "greenwashing," where companies may overstate their environmental or social responsibility without making substantive changes to their core operations.26 Some critics further argue that current ESG ratings tend to focus more on the financial risks that climate change and social issues pose to a company's profitability, rather than assessing the actual negative impact that the company's operations have on the environment and society.28 This raises fundamental questions about whether ESG investing truly drives positive change or primarily serves as a mechanism for managing financial risk. Additionally, there are ongoing debates about whether ESG activities ultimately benefit shareholders or if they are increasingly driven by what some perceive as "woke" agendas that prioritize social and political goals over financial returns.29

Elon Musk, the CEO of Tesla, has emerged as a particularly outspoken critic of ESG, labeling it a "scam" and even "Satanic".39 His opposition intensified after Tesla, a company whose core product is designed to combat climate change, was removed from the S&P 500 ESG Index.41 Musk argued that ESG ratings are often politically motivated and fail to accurately reflect a company's positive contributions to the world. He pointed to instances where companies with arguably significant negative environmental impacts, such as tobacco and fossil fuel companies, received higher ESG scores than Tesla.41 In Musk's view, ESG should prioritize measuring the real-world impact of a company, particularly its positive contributions, rather than solely focusing on the dollar value of potential risks and returns.50 Tesla itself, in its own impact reports, has echoed Musk's concerns, stating that current ESG methodologies are fundamentally flawed and need to evolve to better measure genuine positive impact.43 The company argues that the significant positive environmental impact of electric vehicles in reducing emissions is often overlooked by ESG rating systems, which tend to focus more on mitigating negative risks.50

However, Tesla's lower ESG scores are frequently attributed to factors beyond just its environmental performance. Social and governance aspects, such as allegations of racial discrimination and poor working conditions at its facilities, as well as Musk's own often controversial behavior, have contributed to its less favorable overall ESG ratings.41 This suggests that Musk's critique might be overly focused on the "E" (Environmental) component of ESG and dismissive of the "S" (Social) and "G" (Governance) aspects, which are also integral to the principles of responsible and sustainable business practices.

Implementing and effectively measuring ESG strategies presents a range of practical challenges. These include the absence of universally standardized reporting frameworks, the constantly evolving landscape of ESG regulations, the complexities of managing vast amounts of data, and the inherent difficulties in accurately quantifying ESG-related risks and impacts.59 The lack of a single, globally accepted standard for ESG reporting compels companies to often adhere to multiple different frameworks, which introduces significant complexity and hinders the ability to make meaningful comparisons between companies.60 The process of collecting and managing ESG data across diverse global operations and intricate supply chains can be particularly cumbersome and often requires substantial resources.66 Furthermore, ongoing debates persist regarding the materiality of various ESG factors and the optimal way to balance potentially conflicting environmental, social, and governance objectives.37

The practical difficulties in implementing and measuring ESG underscore the fact that this is still a relatively nascent and rapidly evolving field. While the underlying intentions behind ESG are generally positive – to encourage more sustainable and responsible corporate behavior – the current lack of mature and universally accepted standards creates significant hurdles for companies genuinely trying to integrate ESG principles into their core operations and for investors attempting to make informed decisions based on available ESG ratings.26

Tesla's Paradox: Green Success Amidst Anti-ESG Rhetoric

Tesla's remarkable success story in the electric vehicle market is deeply intertwined with government incentives and policies aimed at fostering the adoption of renewable energy and reducing carbon emissions.72 These policies, which often involve market-based mechanisms like subsidies and tax credits to encourage the uptake of EVs, can be viewed as aligned with broader neoliberal economic trends that seek to utilize market forces to achieve environmental objectives.80

Government-backed incentives, including substantial federal tax credits (up to $7,500 in the United States) and various state-level rebate programs, have played a crucial role in making electric vehicles more financially accessible to a wider range of consumers, thereby significantly driving demand for Tesla's innovative vehicles.72 California's Zero-Emission Vehicle (ZEV) program has proven to be particularly advantageous for Tesla. This program allows Tesla, as a manufacturer solely focused on electric vehicles, to earn valuable credits for every EV it sells. These credits can then be sold to other, more traditional automakers who struggle to meet the ZEV mandate requirements, generating billions of dollars in revenue for Tesla.75 Furthermore, Tesla received a significant loan from the US Department of Energy in its early years, which provided crucial financial support for the establishment of its first mass-market manufacturing facility.77

The overarching global movement towards achieving net-zero emissions by the year 2050 87 is also creating a highly favorable long-term market environment for electric vehicles. Policies aimed at gradually phasing out the sale of new internal combustion engine vehicles 89, coupled with substantial investments in the development of a robust charging infrastructure 78, are further bolstering the growth of the electric vehicle market, directly benefiting Tesla as a recognized leader in this sector.87

Despite Elon Musk's highly public criticisms of ESG, Tesla's core business operations are fundamentally aligned with the goals of environmental sustainability. The company's primary product, electric vehicles, directly contributes to a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions compared to traditional gasoline-powered cars.41 Moreover, Tesla has expanded its business to include renewable energy generation through its SolarCity division and offers various energy storage solutions, further solidifying its commitment to environmental goals.57 The company's mission statement and its regular impact reports consistently emphasize its dedication to accelerating the world's transition towards sustainable energy.57

This creates a seemingly paradoxical situation where the leader of a company deeply involved in promoting environmental sustainability actively denounces the very framework (ESG) designed to assess such efforts. While Musk's criticisms may stem from specific concerns about the methodologies used by ESG rating agencies, the fact remains that Tesla's core business directly addresses a critical aspect of environmental sustainability – the reduction of carbon emissions from transportation, a major contributor to climate change. This fundamental environmental benefit appears to be in direct conflict with Musk's outright dismissal of ESG as a "scam."

Adding another layer to this complex picture are reports suggesting that Musk's personal views on climate change may be evolving, with some suggesting a downplaying of its severity.98 His increasing focus on other ventures, such as artificial intelligence and space exploration 98, might indicate a shift in his personal priorities, even as Tesla continues to be a dominant force in the electric vehicle market. This raises questions about the long-term commitment to environmental sustainability as the primary driving force behind Tesla, regardless of the company's continued production of EVs.

Despite Musk's personal stance, Tesla as a company actively participates in and benefits significantly from green initiatives and policies. Its reliance on ZEV credits for a substantial portion of its profits clearly demonstrates a direct financial benefit derived from these policies.84 The company has also been known to advocate for the continuation and expansion of policies that support the adoption of electric vehicles and the growth of renewable energy.84 Furthermore, Tesla's own impact reports detail its ongoing efforts to minimize its manufacturing footprint, increase its use of renewable energy sources in its production facilities, and promote the recycling of its battery packs.95 This suggests that, regardless of its leader's public skepticism towards ESG, the economic realities of the market and the existing regulatory landscape provide strong incentives for Tesla to continue embracing sustainability as a core part of its business strategy.

The current global economic climate, heavily influenced by the resurgence of protectionist sentiments as exemplified by "Trumpism," presents significant challenges for smaller manufacturing-dependent economies. The volatility in tariffs and exchange rates creates an unstable environment that necessitates constant adaptation and strategic maneuvering. While these nations seek to navigate these uncertainties through negotiation and diversification, the long-term implications remain to be seen.

The debate surrounding ESG principles, highlighted by skepticism from established institutions and outright opposition from influential figures, reflects the complexities and ongoing evolution of measuring corporate sustainability and responsibility. The lack of standardized metrics and the potential for "greenwashing" raise legitimate concerns about the effectiveness and reliability of ESG ratings.

The case of Tesla, a company achieving remarkable success in the green sector while its leader publicly denounces ESG, underscores the intricate interplay between economic realities, political ideologies, and environmental concerns. Tesla's growth has been significantly fueled by policies promoting sustainability, demonstrating the potential of well-designed incentives. Despite Musk's personal views, Tesla's core business and operational practices continue to contribute to a more sustainable future, highlighting a potential disconnect between individual rhetoric and corporate impact. In this evolving landscape, a balanced approach that acknowledges both the economic pressures and the growing imperative for sustainable practices will be crucial for navigating the path forward.

引用的著作

1. The origins, nature, and future of “Trumpism” | Cairn.info, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://shs.cairn.info/dossiers-2024-6-page-1?lang=en

2. Political positions of Donald Trump - Wikipedia, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_positions_of_Donald_Trump

3. What to know about the Trump tariffs upending global trade and markets - AP News, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://apnews.com/article/trump-tariffs-economic-impact-trade-markets-3e38352ab5693852bfd9bc8dd2ac2d56

4. How Trump's Tariffs Could Lead to Global Recession | TIME, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://time.com/7275987/trump-tariffs-global-economy-recession-trade-war-asia-world-impacts/

5. Vietnam among hardest hit by Trump tariffs - World Socialist Web Site, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2025/04/08/czbw-a08.html

6. Trump's Tariffs Pose a Structural Threat to Vietnam's Economy - Stratfor, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/trumps-tariffs-pose-structural-threat-vietnams-economy

7. Trump's tariffs threaten Thai economy with GDP contraction: experts - Nation Thailand, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.nationthailand.com/business/economy/40048561

8. Trump's trade shockwaves hit Thailand, Thai economists warn, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.nationthailand.com/business/economy/40048544

9. Trump's Tariff: A test to Malaysia's trade resilience | Astro Awani, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/trump-s-tariff-test-malaysia-s-trade-resilience-515924

10. Trump's tariffs: What is the impact on Malaysia? | The Star, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2025/04/07/trumps-tariffs-what-is-the-impact-on-malaysia

11. How Malaysia's manufacturing industries can survive Trump's reciprocal tariff, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://theedgemalaysia.com/node/750924

12. The Trump Administration's Trade War Heats Up: What Comes Next? - The Darden Report, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://news.darden.virginia.edu/2025/04/04/the-trump-administrations-trade-war-heats-up-what-comes-next/

13. Trump's Trade War is a Major Economic and Strategic Blunder, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.americanprogress.org/article/trumps-trade-war-is-a-major-economic-and-strategic-blunder/

14. What Trump's tariff announcement means for global trade pros - Thomson Reuters tax, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/blog/what-trumps-global-tariff-announcement-means-for-trade-professionals/

15. Trump's America exits the global trade order | What we are reading | Hinrich Foundation, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.hinrichfoundation.com/research/what-we-are-reading/trump-america-exits-the-global-trade-order/

16. Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Declares National Emergency to Increase our Competitive Edge, Protect our Sovereignty, and Strengthen our National and Economic Security - The White House, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/04/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-declares-national-emergency-to-increase-our-competitive-edge-protect-our-sovereignty-and-strengthen-our-national-and-economic-security/

17. Why Malaysia is avoiding a WTO showdown with Trump despite flawed tariff claims, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2025/04/10/why-malaysia-is-avoiding-a-wto-showdown-with-trump-despite-flawed-tariff-claims/172405

18. Trumpism - Wikipedia, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trumpism

19. Understanding Trumpism: Nationalism, Populism, and Industrialism ..., 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.baronpa.com/library/understanding-trumpism-nationalism-populism-and-industrialism

20. The Core Values of Donald Trump: A Balanced Examination, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://values.institute/the-core-values-of-donald-trump-a-balanced-examination/

21. 2024 Republican Party Platform - The American Presidency Project, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/2024-republican-party-platform

22. Trumpism Doesn't Work - Niskanen Center, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.niskanencenter.org/trumpism-doesnt-work/

23. What are the three characteristics of Trumpism?: A Discourse Analysis of Trump's Four Major Campaign Speeches - eRepository @ Seton Hall, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1038&context=pa

24. en.wikipedia.org, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trumpism#:~:text=Trumpism%20has%20authoritarian%20leanings%20and,in%20the%20mid%2Dlate%202010s.

25. Donald Trump and fascism - Wikipedia, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump_and_fascism

26. The rise of ESG scepticism in Europe? - Taylor Wessing, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.taylorwessing.com/en/insights-and-events/insights/2025/01/the-rise-of-esg-scepticism-in-europe

27. The Measurement of Impact Investors in an Age of Skepticism - Harvard Business School, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.hbs.edu/private-capital/Documents/Events/The%20Measurement%20of%20Impact%20Investors%20in%20an%20Age%20of%20Skepticism.pdf

28. ESG is broken — but can it be fixed? - Eidosmedia.com, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.eidosmedia.com/updater/technology/ESG-has-broken-down-can-it-be-fixed

29. What The Economist Gets Wrong About ESG - Ethical Systems, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.ethicalsystems.org/what-the-economist-gets-wrong-about-esg/

30. The criticism of ESG: why is it becoming controversial? - UCEM, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.ucem.ac.uk/whats-happening/articles/criticism-of-esg/

31. As ESG reporting becomes mainstream, complex challenges persist | EY - India, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.ey.com/en_in/insights/climate-change-sustainability-services/as-esg-reporting-becomes-mainstream-complex-challenges-persist

32. The problem with ESG scores - Stewart Investors, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.stewartinvestors.com/global/en/all/insights/the-problem-with-esg-scores.html

33. The Impracticality of Standardizing ESG Reporting | Fraser Institute, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/ESG-myths-realities-impracticality-of-standardizing-ESG-reporting.pdf

34. ESG Investing: Rising Trend Amid Greenwashing Concerns | Earth.Org, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://earth.org/esg-investing/

35. Anti-ESG Movement: Voices Challenging ESG Investing, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.esgvoices.com/post/anti-esg-movement-voices-challenging-esg-investing

36. How to address sustainable investment backlash and improve ESG reporting, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.weforum.org/stories/2021/12/esg-sustainable-investment-backlash/

37. ESG Moving Forward: Lessons from the Past, Visions for the Future | Baker Institute, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/esg-moving-forward-lessons-past-visions-future

38. ESG is essential for companies to maintain their social license - McKinsey, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/sustainability/our-insights/does-esg-really-matter-and-why

39. Musk rips 'Satanic' ESG as World Economic Forum meets and discusses controversial investment regime | Fox Business, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/musk-rips-satanic-esg-world-economic-forum-controversial-investment-regime

40. ESG in 2023: Politics and Polemics, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2023/02/06/esg-in-2023-politics-and-polemics/

41. Can Elon Musk save ESG? - Trellis Group, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://trellis.net/article/can-elon-musk-save-esg/

42. Elon Musk calls ESG a “scam” - World News Group, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://wng.org/opinions/elon-musk-calls-esg-a-scam-1654166891

43. Tesla CEO Elon Musk Comes Out Against ESG | IWF - Independent Women's Forum, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.iwf.org/2022/05/19/tesla-ceo-elon-musk-comes-out-against-esg/

44. Elon Musk vs ESG - PBA - Pro Bono Australia, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://probonoaustralia.com.au/news/2022/06/elon-musk-vs-esg/

45. Why Elon Musk and Peter Thiel Are Wrong on ESG Investing | Opinion - Newsweek, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.newsweek.com/why-elon-musk-peter-thiel-are-wrong-esg-investing-opinion-1764457

46. Navigating the Complexity of ESG: Insights from Elon Musk's Critique - Directors Institute, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.directors-institute.com/post/navigating-the-complexity-of-esg-insights-from-elon-musk-s-critique

47. In May, Elon Musk went on the warpath against the investment model known by the initials ESG, short for “environmental, social and governance” principles., 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://enewspaper.latimes.com/infinity/article_share.aspx?guid=e3a1925a-b08c-4726-b6ae-8ff448334ba7

48. Musk responds to Tesla ESG ratings | ESG Investing: Sustainability News, Events & Awards, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.esginvesting.co.uk/2023/06/musk-responds-to-tesla-esg-rating/

49. Elon Musk says 'ESG is the devil' with tobacco firms trouncing Tesla in social-responsibility ratings - Markets Insider, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/elon-musk-tesla-stock-price-esg-tobacco-green-investing-twitter-2023-6

50. Why Tesla CEO Elon Musk Is Calling ESG a 'Scam' - Time, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://time.com/6180638/tesla-esg-index-musk/

51. Tesla Missed the ESG Moment, and Twitter Could Bury It - TriplePundit, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2023/tesla-twitter-elon-musk-esg/766671

52. Tesla, Inc.: addressing ESG challenges | Emerald Insight, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/tcj-12-2022-0198/full/pdf?title=tesla-inc-addressing-esg-challenges

53. Elon Musk says 'ESG is the devil' with tobacco firms trouncing Tesla in social-responsibility ratings : r/environment - Reddit, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.reddit.com/r/environment/comments/14a00cb/elon_musk_says_esg_is_the_devil_with_tobacco/

54. Tesla Removed From S&P 500 ESG Index, Musk: "ESG Is a Scam" - Impakter, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://impakter.com/tesla-removed-from-sp-500-esg-index-musk-esg-is-a-scam/

55. Elon Musk Critical of ESG - Nasdaq, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/elon-musk-critical-of-esg

56. Is Elon Musk confused about ESG or does Tesla have a point about Impact? - Socialsuite, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.socialsuitehq.com/articles/is-elon-musk-confused-about-esg-or-does-tesla-have-a-point-about-impact

57. Tesla 2021 Impact Report, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/2021-tesla-impact-report.pdf

58. Tesla 2020 Impact Report, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/2020-tesla-impact-report.pdf

59. Challenges of implementing an ESG strategy – The Arthur Lok Jack Global School of Business, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://lokjackgsb.edu.tt/challenges-esg/

60. The 5 biggest hurdles to effective ESG reporting - CCH Tagetik | Wolters Kluwer, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.wolterskluwer.com/en/expert-insights/the-5-biggest-hurdles-to-effective-esg-reporting

61. The 5 main challenges of ESG reporting and best practice - Bedford Consulting, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://bedfordconsulting.com/the-5-main-challenges-of-esg-reporting-and-best-practice/

62. ESG: From Challenges to Opportunities | United Nations Development Programme, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.undp.org/belarus/stories/esg-challenges-opportunities

63. Top 6 ESG Issues For Companies to Tackle - Ethics & Compliance Initiative, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.ethics.org/top-6-esg-issues-for-companies-to-tackle/

64. Navigating ESG Implementation Hurdles And Building Investor Trust - Forbes, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesfinancecouncil/2024/06/04/navigating-esg-implementation-hurdles-and-building-investor-trust/

65. Six key challenges for financial institutions to deal with ESG risks - PwC, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.pwc.com/vn/en/publications/vietnam-publications/six-key-challenges-for-financial-institutions-to-deal-with-ESG-risks.html

66. ESG Reporting: What Are the Challenges and Opportunities Faced by Organizations in Driving Change? - The Global Treasurer, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.theglobaltreasurer.com/2024/07/19/better-esg-reporting-an-important-step-in-driving-change/

67. The challenges and best practices of ESG reporting | Ocorian, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.ocorian.com/insights/challenges-and-best-practices-esg-reporting

68. ESG Reporting: Strategies, Challenges and Opportunities - APLANET, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://aplanet.org/resources/esg-reporting/

69. ESG is dead, long live ESG | IESE Insight, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.iese.edu/insight/articles/esg-debate-alex-edmans/

70. Pushing back, moving forward: Understanding the evolution of ESG - WTW, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.wtwco.com/en-hk/insights/2022/12/pushing-back-moving-forward-understanding-the-evolution-of-esg

71. ESG Ratings – the challenges of comparison and reliability | Structured Finance In Brief, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.structuredfinanceinbrief.com/2024/07/esg-ratings-the-challenges-of-comparison-and-reliability/

72. Tesla Cars Reach 8,000 Pre-Federal Rebate Sales In 2022 - RP3@PublicPower.org, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.rp3.publicpower.org/writing/tesla-sells-over-8000-evs-before-the-end-of-the-federal-rebate

73. Electric Vehicle and Energy Incentives | Tesla Support, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.tesla.com/support/incentives

74. Tesla customers cite incentives as factor behind EV purchase: JD Power study - Teslarati, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-customers-incentives-reason-ev-purchase-jd-power-study/

75. Gov. Newsom Says California Subsidies Powered Tesla's Success, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.govtech.com/policy/gov-newsom-says-california-subsidies-powered-teslas-success

76. Who Benefits from EV Subsidies? The Complicating Role of Zero-Emissions Vehicle Standards - Resources Magazine, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.resources.org/common-resources/who-benefits-from-ev-subsidies-the-complicating-role-of-zero-emissions-vehicle-standards/

77. TESLA | Department of Energy, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.energy.gov/lpo/tesla

78. Policies to promote electric vehicle deployment – Global EV Outlook 2021 – Analysis - IEA, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.iea.org/reports/global-ev-outlook-2021/policies-to-promote-electric-vehicle-deployment

79. Tesla's Global Strategy: Taking Over the World, One EV at a Time - Accelingo, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.accelingo.com/teslas-global-strategy/

80. All Economic Policy Is Climate Policy: Tools for a Post-Neoliberal Green Transition, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/all-economic-policy-is-climate-policy/

81. Clean Energy Neoliberalism: Climate, Tax Credits, and Racial Justice - Roosevelt Institute, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/clean-energy-neoliberalism/

82. Neoliberalism Poisoned Climate Action And Renewables Are The Antidote, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://australiainstitute.org.au/post/neoliberalism-poisoned-climate-action-and-renewables-are-the-antidote/

83. Electricity Transformed: Neoliberalism and Local Energy in the United States - David J. Hess, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， http://davidjhess.org/uploads/3/4/8/1/34811322/antipode2011.draft.pdf

84. Tesla built Musk's vast wealth through climate credits. Trump may end them. - E&E News, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.eenews.net/articles/musk-made-a-fortune-on-climate-credits-trump-is-targeting-them/

85. Short Circuit: The High Cost of Electric Vehicle Subsidies - Manhattan Institute, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://manhattan.institute/article/short-circuit-the-high-cost-of-electric-vehicle-subsidies

86. Tesla Motor's Government Income | North Carolina Journal of Law & Technology, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://journals.law.unc.edu/ncjolt/blogs/tesla-motors-government-income/

87. Electric vehicles - IEA, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.iea.org/energy-system/transport/electric-vehicles

88. Electrifying the Road to Net-Zero: Implications of Electric Vehicles and Carbon Emission Coefficient Factors in European Power Systems - MDPI, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/16/12/5084

89. The role of electric vehicles in achieving net zero. - EON, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.eonnext.com/blog/the-role-of-electric-vehicles-in-achieving-net-zero

90. The road to net zero: why do UK consumers hesitate to buy electric cars?, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.bennettinstitute.cam.ac.uk/blog/the-road-to-net-zero/

91. Mobility's net-zero transition: A look at opportunities and risks | McKinsey, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/our-insights/mobilitys-net-zero-transition-a-look-at-opportunities-and-risks

92. Improving economics strengthen the case for ambitious EV policies to achieve Paris commitments - International Council on Clean Transportation, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://theicct.org/improving-economics-strengthen-the-case-for-ambitious-ev-policies-to-achieve-paris-commitments-dec23/

93. Net-Zero Road Transport By 2050 Still Possible, As Electric Vehicles Set To Quintuple By 2025 | BloombergNEF, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://about.bnef.com/blog/net-zero-road-transport-by-2050-still-possible-as-electric-vehicles-set-to-quintuple-by-2025/

94. Sustainable and Clean Energy: The Case of Tesla Company - ResearchGate, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366057251_Sustainable_and_Clean_Energy_The_Case_of_Tesla_Company

95. Impact | Tesla, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.tesla.com/impact

96. 2023 Tesla Impact Report, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/2023-tesla-impact-report-highlights.pdf

97. Navigating the ESG Landscape: An In-depth SWOT Analysis and Strategic Recommendations for Tesla's Sustainable Growth - Atlantis Press, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.atlantis-press.com/article/126002481.pdf

98. This is why Tesla is not sustainable, as it liked you to think - iNSnet, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.insnet.org/why-tesla-is-not-as-sustainable-as-you-think/

99. After Years of Feasting on EV Subsidies, Elon Musk Is Now Content to Watch Them Die, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/02/elon-musk-tesla-ev-subsidies-donald-trump-flip-flop/

100. Elon Musk's far-right lurch helps the fossil fuel industry - Ketan Joshi, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://ketanjoshi.co/2022/11/26/elon-musks-far-right-lurch-helps-the-fossil-fuel-industry/

101. Tesla's Carbon Credit Revenue Soars to $2.76 Billion Amid Profit Drop - CarbonCredits.com, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://carboncredits.com/teslas-carbon-credit-revenue-soars-to-2-76-billion-amid-profit-drop/

102. Elon Musk Advocates for Sustainable Energy in Conversation with Trump Amidst EV Industry Challenges - ESG News, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://esgnews.com/elon-musk-advocates-for-sustainable-energy-in-conversation-with-trump-amidst-ev-industry-challenges/

Tesla, Inc. ESG Score - S&P Global, 檢索日期：4月 11, 2025， https://www.spglobal.com/esg/scores/results?cid=4574287

PS：This article was generated by AI